Well, This Sounds Stupid.

There’s an academic Bujold study coming out, which is good. But this is what it’s about, which is nonsensical:

Acclaimed science fiction scholar Edward James traces how Bujold emerged from fanzine culture to win devoted male and female readers despite working in genres–military SF, space opera–perceived as solely by and for males.

“Garsh, I’m an academical press, so very steeped in literature. And that’s why I’ve never heard of anybody named Leigh Brackett or Catherine Moore or Andre Norton, or 75% of the Star Trek novelists, or Rebecca Meluch who lived right down the pike, or Elizabeth Moon. Yup, there weren’t any other women writing space opera or military sf, and never mind that Bujold read all these books growing up, and so did her readers.”

(See, I hope this is just a really stupid blurb by the university press, and not a preview of the book as parade of ignorance.)

I would actually argue that space opera was almost exclusively a female-written genre during the Eighties and early Nineties, and that male writers came back to it mostly because of David Weber and the huge success of Honor Harrington. And since most people noted at that time that it was C.L Forester meets Anne McCaffrey telepathic partnership, I would argue that David Weber knew the audience he was aiming for was one formed by female authors.

But I don’t think women writers were cut out of space opera in any way. What I recall is that Eighties/Nineties space operas (by women and men) often included romance. The popularity of this strand led to romance publishers putting out sf romances, which became sf and fantasy and paranormal romances. After several years of experimentation, sf/f publishers started putting out huge numbers of paranormal romances with a few sf romances mixed in, while space operas largely lost their romance tinges because publishers didn’t want romance there.

(And then self-publishing allowed anybody to put this stuff out, solely according to personal preference, which is where we are today. Goodness knows what the numbers are, and who would even try to figure it out?)

As for military sf — well, Star Trek was military sf, and so were many seminal works of written sf. The amount of realism about combat and the naval experience that was included differed among different female authors, but the same applied to male authors. Star Trek explicitly drew from C.L. Forester’s Hornblower and from Patrick O’Brien’s then-less known books, and many Star Trek authors read them for inspiration, and then tackled similar themes, trying to meaningfully depict the burden of command, military justice, being a prisoner of war, and the like. The popularity of space opera seems to have allowed contemplation of resuming writing military sf of a less bleak nature than Drake’s pre-Leary/Mundy work; and indeed, Baen released several “cheery” military sf works by both men and women in the late eighties and early nineties. The Sassinak co-written books featuring Anne McCaffrey with women co-writers Nye and Moon were typical of this. But McCaffrey’s first Dragonrider trilogy was also more or less military sf, but set in a world where the war was against Threadfall, and her Ship Who Sang stories dealt with military issues. She wrote a military-set Gothic/mystery romance or two, which wasn’t surprising because her dad was military. One of the first sf books Andre Norton wrote back in the 1950’s was Star Guard, which was military sf, and her Sword trilogy was comprised of a good chunk of military fiction, and many of her heroes had WWII experience and post-WWII assignments.

I could go on and on like this, and I’m sure I could go trawling through people’s pulp collections to the same effect, if I wanted to go back further. It used to be very typical to have your sf hero or heroine have WWI experience; and before that, in the scientific romances, it was typical to give them military/war experience in the US Civil War, or the UK Boer War, or in Indian-fighting in the Old West or the Old Northwest or the Northwest Frontier of Canada. (If you want someone to have a variety of useful skills, this is a good shorthand way to provide them.) But I’ll stop here.

Bujold is remarkable because she is a Darned Good Writer. She would be remarkable in any company of writers, male or female or little gray alien.

But though she has planted fields in her own unique way, plenty of people had planted there before her. She did not break new ground. Nor was she the only woman in those fields during the dawn of her career. Quite the opposite, as my paperback bookshelves tell me.

UPDATE: I forgot to mention Jo Clayton’s Seventies/Eighties Diadem series from DAW Books. There were nine books of it, it focused on the space opera/planetary adventure perils and triumphs of a single female character, Aleytys; and it was a blend of Seventies/Eighties historical saga romance with Seventies feminist sword and sorcery tropes. (She traveled around to low-tech planets seeking alien artifacts. Unlike Lara Croft, she got captured or raped or enslaved every book, practically, and then she killed all the rapists with her magic alien-tech crown. I think her thief boyfriend survived all the books, although I don’t really remember.) As with every other sf/f book I came across in a library or open bookshelf, I read them all even though I didn’t like them. My impression was that they sold like hotcakes. Anyway, the series ran from 1977-1986, and she wrote many other sf/f books until her too-early decease.

UPDATE: I haven’t even mentioned C.J. Cherryh, who was probably the Eighties’ most prominent author in both space opera and hard sf. Captain Signy Mallory of Downbelow Station? Military sf. The Pride of Chanur series? Space opera. The Morgaine series? Stargate: SG-1 on horses, years before Stargate was even invented. Serpent’s Reach? SF horror. Cherryh is still alive and writing and popular, so it’s silly of me to forget her! Cherryh has won three Hugos and was nominated seven times (1979 (nom for Best Novel, won for Best Short Story), 1982 (won Best Novel), 1983, 1986 (nom for Best Novel and Best Novella), 1989 (won Best Novel)). She also won the Campbell Award for Best New Writer in 1977.

Less happily, one must remember that the now-notorious pedophile and child abuser Marion Zimmer Bradley’s entire Darkover series was technically space opera as well as planetary adventure. It was wildly popular and influential during the Seventies and early Eighties, and was a focus of female fandom. Bradley was nominated twice for Best Novel in the Hugos, in 1963 and 1978. Both were Darkover novels.



Filed under Uncategorized

7 responses to “Well, This Sounds Stupid.

  1. Pingback: Well, This Sounds Stupid. | Aliens in This World | Head Noises

  2. Kinda sad that we have to figure it’s at best 50/50 on if a really cool sounding book was done by someone with a clue or not.

    My husband despairs of my podcast listening habits, because I seem to have a knack for finding painfully/willfully ignorant “experts.” And listening anyways, until even I can’t find an excuse for it.
    How ignorant? One was a supposed expert on Satanism in America…who held it was mostly a freak-out about normal religions, because the FBI’s symbols list had symbols from pretty much everything that wasn’t mainstream Protestantism. It apparently never occurred to him that this was because of the Satanists, even though even slight familiarity with historic “magic” fads should’ve made it clear.

  3. Reblogged this on westfargomusings and commented:
    Women haven’t been kept out of the field, and certainly not the Hugo Awards, despite what many SJWs claim. There’s a fairly good list of female authors from decades past.

    • Thank you — but this isn’t even a complete list of the famous female authors of sf/f, much less of all the lesser lights, or those forgotten even by feminist collectors of the Eighties and Nineties.

      It’s the reversal that kills me. After feminist fans spending a good thirty years digging up women writers and pointing out that the only time women weren’t a super-obvious part of the field was right after WWII (when a lot of women and men were busy having kids) the new persons calling themselves feminists have largely buried all their predecessors in oblivion. We live in a world where rare and out of print stuff is relatively easy to get your mitts on, but the purposefully ignorant aren’t reading old sf/f because they know it must be bad and racisss. Sigh.

      The most inconvenient feminist fact about male-dominated sf in the Golden Age is that practically everything John W. Campbell published went through Catherine “Kay” Tarrant, first and last. For most of fandom, her title was “secretary,” but she was actually on the masthead of Astounding as the assistant editor who read submissions by newbies, and then copy-edited stuff going to be published. Campbell also gave her practically limitless power to find and censor out sexual references that could get Astounding Stories banned from drugstores by local authorities, and everyone in sf was aware of this. Many waged constant mental war to get something past her. She ruled the Golden Age with an iron hand, yet Kay Tarrant has no Wikipedia page.

      Before the Golden Age, magazines like Amazing Stories and Weird Tales were full of women writers. The most famous and shocking Weird Tales cover artist was Margaret Brundage, who drew more nekkid women in distress than anybody I can think of. She worked in pastels, of all things, so her career was restricted mostly to Chicago-published magazines. But what an artist! And how inconveniently outside normal definitions of feminism!

      • Oh, I know it wasn’t complete. One of my favorites (Barbara Hambly) wasn’t mentioned, though I don’t believe she’s been nominated for any Hugos. Most of the stuff I’ve been reading lately has been older.

      • No, I don’t think she ever was. Most of her sf was tie-ins for Star Wars or Star Trek, and most of her other work was fantasy (which a lot of really old-school Hugo voters still won’t vote for, since it used to be a science fiction award). But oddly, she has never even been nominated for a World Fantasy Award, despite doing real groundbreaking work early on, and continuing in excellence for many decades.

  4. Pingback: That Bujold Post | Aliens in This World

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.