I got a meme post either removed or shadowbanned from a fairly orthodox Catholic subreddit.
(UPDATE BELOW: Nope, I didn’t.)
Apparently, it’s a bad deal to point out, in a meme or the comments, that:
a) Utilitarian arguments against the death penalty are not moral arguments
b) The “seamless garment theory” is not official teaching, and it’s prudential
c) The “seamless garment theory” was invented by Cardinal Bernardin, who was a Very Bad Man and facilitated tons of p*dophile activity
d) The “seamless garment theory” was invented to weaken and dissipate the pro-life movement against abortion and euthanasia, and eventually led to many pro-life Catholics on the left becoming only anti-death penalty for adults, not for babies
I mean, I know a lot of people were not old enough to live through this stuff, but it’s not exactly a secret.
Of course, there was also:
e) Pointing out that if utilitarian arguments against the death penalty are true, the Church always had the obligation to fight the death penalty by supporting more and better prisons, feeding the prisoners as its biggest alms, etc.
(I didn’t get a chance to point out that in fact, the Church generally opposed the existence of prisons, historically, because it was considered much crueller than death. It was very controversial when ecclesiastical figures with temporal powers started running prisons, instead of miraculously unlocking all the doors just by walking by, or getting the secular authorities to agree to free certain prisoners on certain days of the year.)
f) Pointing out that if utilitarian arguments against the death penalty are true, then God is really stingy by only providing evil souls and demons with Hell. Whereas in actual fact, Hell exists as a matter of justice.
So I don’t even know why my post disappeared. Heh, maybe someday I will find out.
UPDATE: It’s back. Apparently some setting got messed up accidentally, so actually I didn’t make the achievement! Well, good. I feel better about participating in discussion groups, if I’m not going to have to worry about some hot take being too hot.