We have a fun second reading today – which has been used nicely by St. Augustine, and abused by a lot of people, especially the late Alister Crowley. It is Rom. 13:8-10.
The beginning of verse 8 is translated in the Lectionary as “Owe nothing to anyone.”
The literal wording is “Y’all, owe nothing to nobody (Medeni meden opheilete).” Medeni is dative singular masculine (to nobody, to no man), and meden is the object noun, in accusative singular neuter (nothing). Opheilete is in the imperative, 2nd person plural, so St. Paul is commanding this.
The verse continues, “Except to love one another” (ei me, to agapan allelous). The Lectionary turns this into “except that YOU love one another.”
Poke poke poke, y’all must do it and not just hear about the infinitive, huh? I understand this lectionary translation move.
Allelous could also be translated as “each other,” if you like that better, but “one another” is a nice sonorous English way to say it.
The verse continues, “For the one loving (ho gar agapon) the other/another [person] (ton heteron) has fulfilled the Law (nomon pepleroken).”
So as you would expect, we are talking about agape love, love that wants the highest good for the other – and not sexual, parental, familial, or friendly love.
To fulfill the old Law is to make it perfect and complete, to fill it up with the meaning and actions for which it waited, after being given by God, and His prophet Moses, as a sign and a prep school for Israel.
Christ’s new Law and new love covers up what is no longer needed and used, without destroying what was once useful and holy.
Verse 9 explains further. “For this [reason] (to gar), it is recapped (anakephalaioutai, to repeat again in a short form, like the content summary at the “head” of a chapter of a book).”
One of the Bible’s weirder literary features is this “time travel” or “circle back,” anakephalosis, where the same event or concept is talked about several times from a different perspective. The Book of Revelation does a ton of this, and it also shows how the Church and what happens to her is the thing that fulfills a lot of Israel’s history and prophesies.
Christian theology shows how, eventually, Christ recaps everything good in existence, in Himself.
So what is recapped in this verse? The old Law is the implied subject being studied. But St. Paul in this verse talks about the commandments that are “in the Word,” and thus defends the old Law as sacred and part of Jesus. Each individual commandment is what is being recapped.
Here’s what the Greek of verse 9 says:
“To gar (for this):
“Ou moicheuseis (Thou shall not do adultery)
“Ou phoneuseis (Thou shall not murder)
“Ou klepheis (Thou shall not steal)
“Ou pseudomartyreseis (Thou shall not fake-witness)
“Ouk epithymeseis (Thou shall not overly-strongly desire/covet).”
“Kai ei tis hetera entole? (And if there be another commandment?)
“En touto to logo (in this Word/saying),
“anakephalaioutai (it is recapped) –
“en to (in this):
“Agapeis (Thou shall love)
“ton plesion sou (thy neighbor)
“hos heauton (as thyself).”
Verse 10 finishes by pointing out that “Love does nothing bad to the neighbor (he agape to plesion kakon ouk ergaxetai).”
“The fullness of the Law is love (pleroma oun nomon he agape).”
That should have polished off the Gnostics, but noooo.
Anyway, the Greek text is doing a lot of work again. Man, I love reading the Bible in Greek.